Photo Credit: Colleen AF Venable
There was a time when most Americans got their news from the local newspaper. Folks knew the editor. They knew the reporter. If they didn't like a story, there was a fair chance they'd run into the writer at church, the grocery store, or the Friday night football game.
Today, millions of Americans get their news from a podcaster they've never met.
That raises an interesting question. If Americans once got their news from the local newspaper and now get it from a podcaster they have never met, what does that do to the way we think, vote, and understand the world?
The answer appears to be quite a bit.
Podcasts have become one of the most popular forms of media in America. People listen while driving to work, feeding cattle, mowing hay, working in the garage, or walking the dog. What used to be quiet time has become listening time. A long commute or a couple hours on a tractor can suddenly become a history lesson, a political debate, or an interview with somebody halfway around the world.
Truth be told, there ain't much new about it.
Long before podcasts, America had another technology that brought a familiar voice directly into people's homes. It was called radio.
During the Great Depression, President Franklin D. Roosevelt used his famous Fireside Chats to speak directly to the American people. Families gathered around their radios and listened as Roosevelt explained bank failures, unemployment, Social Security, rural electrification, and the New Deal. Some of the most progressive legislation in American history came during that era, but Roosevelt understood something many politicians still struggle with today. Before people support an idea, they have to trust the person explaining it.
Many historians believe Roosevelt's greatest skill wasn't public speaking. It was making millions of Americans feel as if he was sitting in their living room talking directly to them. A good podcast works much the same way.
Researchers have found that listening to spoken stories activates parts of the brain connected to memory, language, and imagination. Unlike television, podcasts don't show us the story. We build the pictures ourselves. The listener becomes part of the experience.
That's one reason people develop strong attachments to their favorite hosts. Psychologists call it a parasocial relationship. Spend enough hours listening to somebody and they begin to feel familiar. They feel like a friend riding shotgun down the road, even though they've never met you.
That relationship has enormous implications for politics.
Anyone old enough to remember the 1990s remembers the rise of talk radio. Conservative hosts dominated the airwaves and built loyal audiences that spent hours each week listening to political commentary. Newspapers and television still mattered, but talk radio created an alternative media world that felt more personal than either one.
Today, podcasts have become the digital successor to talk radio.
Researchers studying online media have found that conservative creators built a much larger podcast ecosystem than their progressive counterparts. Conservative shows consistently rank among the most downloaded political podcasts in America. Many are backed by professional media organizations with producers, editors, advertising networks, subscription services, and marketing teams.
Progressive podcasts certainly exist, and some attract large audiences. Yet many analysts argue the political left never built a comparable independent podcast infrastructure. The result looks remarkably similar to the talk radio landscape of thirty years ago.
Millions of Americans now spend more time listening to podcast hosts than they do reading newspapers or watching local television news. Some listeners hear the same host for ten or twenty hours every week. That's a powerful relationship, and the human brain naturally places greater trust in voices that feel familiar.
The good news is podcasts can expose people to new ideas and perspectives. The bad news is that the brain also needs quiet. Scientists have discovered that some of our most important thinking happens when we're not actively consuming information. Daydreaming, reflecting, and simply sitting with our own thoughts helps us process experiences and solve problems.
Maybe that's the real lesson of the podcast age.
In the 1930s Americans gathered around the radio for Roosevelt's Fireside Chats. In the 1990s they tuned into talk radio. Today they slip in earbuds and carry their favorite voices everywhere they go. The technology keeps changing, but the human brain doesn't. We still learn through stories, and we still tend to trust the storytellers we spend the most time listening to.
That's what podcasts do to our brains.
References: The right dominates the online media ecosystem
Tired of watching MAGA dominate rural America?
That's why Rural America Rising PAC exists. We provide direct funding and hands-on support to Democratic and Independent candidates running in rural communities.
A $25 donation to a national or statewide campaign barely gets noticed. A $25 donation to a rural school board, county supervisor, or legislative candidate can help buy signs, literature, digital ads, and voter outreach.
While state and national organizations often overlook rural candidates, Rural America Rising PAC invests where it can make the biggest difference…on the ground, in small towns, and in communities that deserve a voice.
Help us build a stronger future for Rural America, one local race at a time.
